New York Immigration Judge Approval Rates
Explore New York asylum approval rates, grants and denials by fiscal year, with immigration court statistics and links to judge profiles.
Data snapshot: 2026-09-01
FY 2026 · 2025-10-01 – 2026-09-01 · Year to date
State approval rate7.5%
National approval rate7.5%
Grants + denials22,039
Courts5
Immigration court asylum approval rates
| Court | Decisions | Granted | Denied | Other | Approval rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York (NYC) | 23,302 | 968 | 12,512 | 9,822 | 7.2% |
| New York (NYB) | 11,646 | 481 | 4,040 | 7,125 | 10.6% |
| New York (NYV) | 5,220 | 171 | 2,949 | 2,100 | 5.5% |
| Buffalo (BUF) | 2,482 | 40 | 829 | 1,613 | 4.6% |
| Napanoch (ULS) | 75 | 3 | 46 | 26 | — |
FY 2025 · 2024-10-01 – 2025-09-30 · Complete fiscal year
State approval rate39.3%
National approval rate26.2%
Grants + denials15,926
Courts5
Immigration court asylum approval rates
| Court | Decisions | Granted | Denied | Other | Approval rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York (NYC) | 16,690 | 3,259 | 2,090 | 11,341 | 60.9% |
| New York (NYB) | 13,446 | 1,546 | 5,283 | 6,617 | 22.6% |
| New York (NYV) | 5,998 | 1,225 | 1,661 | 3,112 | 42.4% |
| Buffalo (BUF) | 1,787 | 229 | 624 | 934 | 26.8% |
| Napanoch (ULS) | 27 | 0 | 9 | 18 | — |
FY 2024 · 2023-10-01 – 2024-09-30 · Complete fiscal year
State approval rate62.5%
National approval rate49.6%
Grants + denials14,827
Courts5
Immigration court asylum approval rates
| Court | Decisions | Granted | Denied | Other | Approval rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York (NYC) | 15,149 | 4,879 | 801 | 9,469 | 85.9% |
| New York (NYB) | 10,636 | 2,256 | 2,773 | 5,607 | 44.9% |
| New York (NYV) | 7,541 | 1,879 | 1,530 | 4,132 | 55.1% |
| Buffalo (BUF) | 1,258 | 255 | 444 | 559 | 36.5% |
| Napanoch (ULS) | 22 | 0 | 10 | 12 | — |
Immigration judge directory
Grouped by the court listed on each profile. This is not a current employment roster or a record of that judge’s assignment in every fiscal year.
- Adams, LoriNew York (NYC)
- Aikman, Susan, FBuffalo (BUF)
- Akalski, Maria I.New York (NYV)
- Aliferis, ThemistoklisNew York (NYV)
- Auh, Kyung S.New York (NYV)
- Baez, LucyNew York (NYC)
- Bartleson, ThomasNew York (NYB)
- Baumgarten, Mary C.Buffalo (BUF)
- Berich, WatsonNew York (NYC)
- Billings, LucyNew York (NYV)
- Bowen, DeniseNew York (NYV)
- Brennan, Noel A.New York (NYB)
- Burnham, Shayne R.New York (NYV)
- Calvelli, AndrewNew York (NYB)
- Cassin, Olivia L.New York (NYB)
- Christensen, Jesse B.New York (NYB)
- Chung, JenniferNew York (NYB)
- Cohen, RaisaNew York (NYC)
- Connelly, Steven J.Buffalo (BUF)
- Conroy, Charles R.New York (NYV)
- Crawford, Carol A.New York (NYC)
- Cusmano, ChristopherNew York (NYC)
- Dandelet, KyleNew York (NYC)
- DeCure, JohnNew York (NYV)
- Diao, AnnaNew York (NYB)
- Dodd, DianeNew York (NYB)
- Donnolo, PaulaNew York (NYC)
- Douchy, Evalyn P.New York (NYC)
- Durkin, JenniferNew York (NYV)
- Ehrens, LisaNew York (NYC)
- Factor, Samuel M.New York (NYC)
- Fraiden, DavidNew York (NYC)
- Gillman, MarlaNew York (NYC)
- Golovnin, LenaNew York (NYC)
- Gordon-Uruakpa, Vivienne E.New York (NYC)
- Gordon, CynthiaNew York (NYC)
- Graulich, James C.New York (NYB)
- Grogan, EdwardNew York (NYB)
- Habib, FayazNew York (NYB)
- Harbeck, Dorothy A.New York (NYC)
- Henry, JenniferNew York (NYC)
- Hochul, DeniseBuffalo (BUF)
- Holloway, RichardNew York (NYC)
- Hristova, LindaNew York (NYC)
- Jaroch, BrandonBuffalo (BUF)
- Jeannopoulos, AmandaNew York (NYC)
- Khan, Amiena A.New York (NYC)
- Kilker, Jean M.New York (NYC)
- Kim, DavidNew York (NYC)
- Kitchen, JamesNew York (NYC)
- Klahr, Deborah E.New York (NYC)
- Kolbe, MargaretNew York (NYV)
- Kouris, Theodora N.New York (NYC)
- Krasinski, CarolynNew York (NYB)
- Laforest, BrigitteNew York (NYB)
- Lalor, KieranNew York (NYV)
- Lawrence, ClaytonNew York (NYB)
- Lazare-Raphael, ShirleyNew York (NYB)
- Lebreton, TanawaNew York (NYB)
- Lee-Lo, AdrienNew York (NYC)
- Lee, KalennaNew York (NYB)
- Leeds, Frederic G.New York (NYC)
- Ling, Lisa W.New York (NYV)
- Little, Anna C.New York (NYC)
- Lohr, BrandiBuffalo (BUF)
- Lopez, SilviaNew York (NYV)
- Loprest, F. James, JR.New York (NYC)
- Luba, Louis J.New York (NYC)
- Lurye, MariaNew York (NYC)
- Maiellano, GioiaNew York (NYC)
- Mart, H. KevinNew York (NYB)
- Martinez Soler, Dianna Michelle.New York (NYB)
- Mccarthy, James M.New York (NYB)
- Mcfarland, Michael G.New York (NYC)
- Mckee, JamesNew York (NYB)
- Merriman, Joy A.Buffalo (BUF)
- Mishkin, Marion SNew York (NYC)
- Montante Jr., Philip J.Buffalo (BUF)
- Moskow, RobertNew York (NYC)
- Mulligan, Thomas J.New York (NYV)
- Mungoven, ThomasNew York (NYV)
- Navarro, Maria E.New York (NYB)
- Nelson, Barbara A.New York (NYC)
- Norkin, DavidNew York (NYV)
- Ouslander, CharlesNew York (NYV)
- Peal, TieshaNew York (NYC)
- Perl, AdamNew York (NYB)
- Pieters, EdwinNew York (NYC)
- Poczter, Aviva L.New York (NYB)
- Prieto, Francisco R.New York (NYV)
- Ranasinghe, Arya S.New York (NYB)
- Reid, DaraNew York (NYV)
- Reingold, JonathanNew York (NYC)
- Rey Caldas, CarmenNew York (NYC)
- Riley, Teresa L.New York (NYC)
- Rubin, AlexanderBuffalo (BUF)
- Rubin, ShifraNew York (NYV)
- Ruehle, Walter H.Buffalo (BUF)
- Sagerman, Roger F.New York (NYV)
- Samuels, LaurieNew York (NYC)
- Sanon, Chevone Teranza.New York (NYB)
- Schoppert, Douglas B.New York (NYB)
- Schultz, EricBuffalo (BUF)
- Segal, AliceNew York (NYC)
- Sichel, HelenNew York (NYC)
- Siemietkowski, JohnNew York (NYC)
- Singh, RantidevaNew York (NYC)
- Sponzo, Jem C.New York (NYC)
- Staszak, ChristopherBuffalo (BUF)
- Stephens, ChristopherNew York (NYB)
- Taylor, KhalilahNew York (NYB)
- Territola, ToniannNew York (NYV)
- Thompson, Donald W., JR.New York (NYC)
- Tsankov, MimiNew York (NYC)
- ul-Haq, UbaidNew York (NYV)
- Wedderburn, WendyNew York (NYV)
- Weintraub, JacobNew York (NYB)
- Weisert, ThomasNew York (NYB)
- Wright, Virna A.New York (NYC)
- Wyke, William VanNew York (NYC)
- Xu, ShaShaNew York (NYB)
- Zagzoug, RandaNew York (NYC)
Compare annual judge approval rates nationwide →
How to read these rates
Asylum grants ÷ (grants + denials). Other outcomes are excluded from this rate. Historical statistics do not predict an individual case.
State totals follow the court at decision time, not the applicant’s home address. Small samples below 50 grants and denials show no rate. Judge comparison requires at least 100.
Data sources and methodology (Chinese)