ASYLUMJUDGE · IMMIGRATION JUDGE PROFILE
Sheila Mcnulty
Chicago (CHI) · Chicago, IL
Sheila Mcnulty is listed with Chicago (CHI). The database records 6 asylum outcomes: 4 approved, 2 denied, and 0 other outcomes. Historical statistics are informational and cannot predict an individual case. · 2020-01-21 – 2020-05-04
Fewer than 50; rate hidden
Yearly changes
Yearly asylum decision trend
No verified annual data available.
Applicant origin
Asylum decisions by fiscal year and nationality
FY 2026 · 2025-10-01 – 2026-07-01 · EOIR
NationalityDecisionsGrantedDeniedOtherApproval rate
Official appointment record
Judge background and appointment
Official biography
—
View official DOJ/EOIR source →
This page shows only verifiable official appointment and biography records. No departure record does not confirm current service; personnel changes are labeled only with reliable sources.
How to read approval rates
Decision approval rateis approved ÷ (approved + denied). Blue “Other” is shown separately and includes identifiable withholding/CAT protection, cancellation or adjustment, voluntary departure, withdrawal, termination, dismissal, and administrative closure; it is excluded from the rate denominator.Approved share of all outcomesuses approved, denied, and other outcomes in the denominator.
With small samples, a few cases can move the percentage sharply. The page flags samples below 50 and below 200 decisions.
View methodology and sources →
AsylumJudge organizes public EOIR immigration-court data and provides no legal conclusion for any individual case.
Understand immigration judge approval rates
Compare this profile with the site-wide explanation of asylum judge ratings, sample sizes, approval rates, and limitations.
Asylum judge rating & approval rate guide →