ASYLUMJUDGE · IMMIGRATION COURT PROFILE

Philadelphia (PHI)

Philadelphia, PA

FY 2026 · 2025-10-01 – 2026-07-01 · EOIR · These profile totals cover all available years; they are not this fiscal year’s court totals.

Decision approval rate15.6%

Judges17

Asylum decisions2,420

Approved / denied377 / 2,043 / 0

Court judges

Judge profiles · all available years

Select a judge to view yearly and nationality data

Judge profiles · all available yearsDecisionsGrantedDeniedOtherApproval rate

Antonio Capistrano2020-11-18 – 2026-07-01738250488033.9%

John B. Carle2020-01-02 – 2026-06-301,413581832041.1%

Patrick J. Ehlers2020-10-13 – 2022-10-27275131144047.6%

Lauren T. Farber2020-01-14 – 2026-06-29842471371055.9%

Melissa Fox2021-04-15 – 2026-07-0114220122014.1%

Mary A. Futcher2023-08-07 – 2026-06-1618727160014.4%

Ayodele Gansallo2022-04-04 – 2026-06-30450224226049.8%

Annie S. Garcy2020-01-08 – 2023-03-2021915366069.9%

Johanna P. Gaymer2026-06-02 – 2026-07-01203170—Fewer than 50; rate hidden

Forrest W. III Hoover2020-01-03 – 2026-06-171,110254856022.9%

Dawn Kulick2020-03-10 – 2026-07-01368173195047.0%

Mary C. Lee2020-01-07 – 2026-06-301,5835341,049033.7%

Keith Lipiec2026-06-01 – 2026-07-01181170—Fewer than 50; rate hidden

Rosalind K. Malloy2020-01-09 – 2023-05-241365284038.2%

William Mcdermott2020-08-27 – 2026-06-29809481328059.5%

Steven A. Morley2020-01-06 – 2022-06-29259145114056.0%

Joseph C. Scott2020-02-14 – 2026-06-26916337579036.8%

Devin A. Winklosky2026-06-01 – 2026-06-30275220—Fewer than 50; rate hidden

How court data is calculated

Court approval rate is approved ÷ (approved + denied) in this court’s database sample. Judge tenures and sample ranges vary, so court totals are for observation, not predicting a case.

View full methodology →

Pennsylvania · State asylum data and judges

Understand immigration judge approval rates

Compare this profile with the site-wide explanation of asylum judge ratings, sample sizes, approval rates, and limitations.

Asylum judge rating & approval rate guide →